CAR: The search for justice

As the International Criminal Court (ICC) steps up its work in the Central African Republic (CAR), pledging to bring the worst perpetrators of violence to justice, concerted efforts are being made to counter endemic impunity in CAR. But the prevailing insecurity in many parts of the country rules out any quick fix solutions.

ICC Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda announced in September that the ICC was ready to open its second investigation in CAR. According to Bensouda, a preliminary enquiry in February had “gathered and scrupulously analysed relevant information from multiple sources”, leaving no doubt as to the ICC’s right to intervene under the Statute of Rome. “The list of atrocities is endless,” Bensouda emphasized. “I cannot ignore these alleged crimes.” 

The preliminaries may be out of the way now and the ICC set for a full investigation, but there has been no indication from The Hague as to how long it will take before suspects are identified, warrants issued and defendants brought to trial. 

Séléka and the anti-Balaka both wanted for war crimes

A report by the Office of the Prosecutor for the ICC on 24 September provides a detailed account of CAR’s descent into civil war from August 2012 and the role played by both the Séléka insurgents and the anti-Balaka militias which tried to counter the rebellion. The ICC describes a period of persecutions and pogroms in which ordinary citizens were routinely targeted on grounds of their ethnicity and religion. The document echoes earlier reports from organizations like Human Rights Watch (HRW) and the International Federation of Human Rights (FIDH) and testimonies from CAR human rights activists. Bensouda herself accuses Séléka and anti-Balaka fighters of engaging in “crimes against humanity and war crimes, including murder, rape, forced displacement, persecution, pillaging, attacks against humanitarian missions and the use of children under 15 in combat.” 

UN Commission appeals for Christian-Muslim dialogue

The UN’s own International Commission of Inquiry into Human Rights Violations in CAR, set up by UN Security Council Resolution 2127 in December 2013, draws similar conclusions. After a first visit to CAR in March 2014 and follow-up research in April and May, the Commission submitted its preliminary report in June. It highlighted the prevalence of extra-judicial executions, enforced disappearances, torture and arbitrary arrest and detention. Commission President Bernard Muna from Cameroon, formerly deputy prosecutor of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR), warned of “hate speech” stoking tensions and called for urgent dialogue between Muslims and Christians. 

Tensions and terror for the legal profession

The ICC has the clear backing of the government of interim President Catherine Samba Panza. In a 30 May communiqué, referring the situation in CAR to the ICC, Samba Panza’s government spoke of “multiple cases of crimes against humanity and other odious violations of human rights perpetrated since 2012”. 

While the ICC’s work gathers momentum, human rights campaigners and legal experts have repeatedly drawn attention to glaring deficiencies in CAR’s domestic justice system.

"Creating an effective justice system, prisons, police
forces and other key State institutions, virtually from scratch, is a massive
and complex enterprise that cannot be done on the cheap"

Magistrates were given pay increases when Michel Djotodia took power in March 2013.  As with other parts of the administration, however, the justice system operates well below normal capacity, confronting enormous difficulties. The lack of basic resources is an inconvenience. More telling are the risks run every day by magistrates and others. ”If magistrates try to do their job properly, they and their families are targeted,” an assistant prosecutor told IRIN. “At the moment, our priority is saving our own lives.”

“Even in the court rooms there is no guarantee of security,” an official at the ministry of justice complained. “The relations of those facing charges will often come to court to exert pressure.”

Several of those detained have escaped from prison and rejoined the ranks of different armed groups. With CAR police and military structures unable to function properly, soldiers from the French-led Operation Sangaris have arrested fighters from Anti-Balaka militias. But one of Anti-Balaka’s main leaders, Patrice-Édouard Ngaïssona, was subsequently released by the authorities.

Visiting Bangui in April 2014, then UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay warned that CAR was marked by “total impunity, no justice, no law and order apart from that provided by foreign troops”. 

The need for homegrown justice

Pillay called for major legal reforms and the creation of a National Human Rights Commission, but warned: “Creating an effective justice system, prisons, police forces and other key State institutions, virtually from scratch, is a massive and complex enterprise that cannot be done on the cheap.”

In its July 2014 report, Central African Republic: Time for Accountability, Amnesty International criticized the international community’s hesitant approach to CAR’s justice and human rights challenges. 

Amnesty stressed the need for CAR to take a bigger role in administering justice, or face the consequences. “If CAR does not institute its own investigations and prosecutions, many perpetrators of crime under international law will continue to enjoy impunity for their crimes.”

A special criminal court for Bangui

Amnesty’s recommendations included the creation of a “hybrid” tribunal, comprising both CAR citizens and internationals, arguing that such a body could help build the confidence and credibility of the national justice sector. 

CAR appears to be heading in this direction. In August, the government and the UN Mission in CAR (MINUSCA) signed an agreement on the formation of a Special Court, composed of CAR magistrates and legal experts from outside. While the ICC will seek to prosecute the most serious offenders in CAR, the Special Court will tackle violations of human rights and breaches of international humanitarian law, including acts of sexual violence and violations of children’s rights. The court’s foundation will depend on the passing of a law by CAR’s interim parliament, the National Transitional Council (TNC). According to Justice Ministry sources contacted by IRIN, such a law should be in place by the end of 2014. 

Enquiries Unit ready to dig deeper

In April 2014, the government announced the creation of the Special Unit of Inquiries and Instructions (CSEI). Working under the supervision of the prosecutor-general of the Court of Appeal, the Unit’s brief goes well beyond the recent conflict, covering the period from 1 January 2004, nine months into the 10-year rule of François Bozizé. This shows a concern for balance, with the abuses investigated not confined to just one administration. The “serious crimes” to be examined include crimes against humanity, war crimes and crimes of aggression. According to the decree which established it, CSEI is composed of both legal personnel, including judges and prosecutors, along with 20 judicial police officers from the Gendarmerie and the national police. Although welcomed by legal experts and human rights campaigners, there are already concerns about CSEI’s lack of resources and its capacity to carry out in-depth investigations, particularly outside Bangui. 

There were similar reservations about the Mixed Commission of Inquiry set up in May 2013 under the short-lived administration of Michel Djotodia. Headed by senior CAR magistrate Flammarion Gaba, the Commission also gave a prominent role to Mathias Moruba, president of the Observatory of Human Rights (ODH). Other members were drawn from the gendarmerie and military. Although the Commission reportedly received dozens of complaints and requests for damages from victims of human rights violations and other crimes, there have been questions asked about its overall effectiveness. The Commission appears to be no longer operating. 

Convincing the sceptics

The ICC’s professed determination to pursue war criminals and the creation of new institutions within CAR has not convinced everyone. 

 

This is the second time ICC has been involved in CAR. In 2004, the Bozizé government requested ICC intervention against Congolese politician and former rebel leader Jean-Pierre Bemba, alleging widespread human rights violations committed by troops from Bemba’s Movement for the Liberation of Congo (MLC) in 2002 and 2003 after their recruitment by then President Ange-Félix Patassé. 

Bemba was arrested in Belgium in May 2008 and faces two counts of crimes against humanity and three counts of war crimes. The trial started in November 2010. According to the ICC, closing oral statements are due in November 2014.

Benjamin Grekoy, a small businessman, told IRIN he was baffled by the delays. “It is years now since Bemba was arrested and his trial is still not over. Why? When is he going to be judged?”

Grekoy was also sceptical about the government’s commitment to investigate past human rights abuses. “From the time of Bozizé, going on through Djotodia and today with Madame Samba Panza brought us a lot of enquiries, but without any real results,” Grekoy complained.  “It is up to Centrafricans to put down their weapons and stop killing each other. Otherwise we are stuck with enquiries that lead nowhere.”

But Joseph Bindoumi, president of the CAR League of Human Rights (LCDH) is more positive.

“At our level here at LCDH, we think these initiatives are welcome because justice is the most effective weapon in conflict situations,” Bindoumi told IRIN. 

“Each time there is action from the international justice system, the ICC for example, we human rights campaigners should feel encouraged because we know the aim of all this is to halt the actions of criminals. To finish the war, there has to be the threat of punishment. I know all this takes time, but Centrafricans must be patient. They must keep the hope that one day those who have carried out serious human rights abuses must be made accountable for their actions.”

cdk/cs/am/cb